In any courtroom, evidence is the foundation of justice. Attorneys must present facts clearly and persuasively—especially when helping juries or judges understand complex information. Two key terms that often arise in litigation are physical and exhibit evidence in court. These types of evidence can be pivotal in influencing how a jury interprets your case.
But what do these terms actually mean in practice?
Physical Evidence Definition
Physical evidence refers to any tangible object that can help establish facts in a legal proceeding. It is one of the most persuasive types of evidence because it allows jurors to see or touch something connected directly to the case.
According to the Federal Rules of Evidence, physical evidence must be authenticated—meaning the party must prove it is what they claim it to be.
Examples of physical evidence include:
- A weapon used in an alleged crime (e.g., a knife or gun)
- Clothing with blood or DNA
- A damaged vehicle in a personal injury claim
- Surveillance video footage
- A handwritten note
How Physical Evidence Strengthens a Case
Studies consistently show that physical evidence—such as crime scene photos, fingerprints, or forensic reports—has a more powerful impact on jurors than eyewitness testimony alone. One 2001 study found that mock jurors placed greater weight on physical evidence than on eyewitness or confession-based testimony when deciding verdicts.
The strategic use of physical and exhibit evidence in court can make a dramatic difference in how the facts are perceived.
What Is Exhibit Evidence?
Exhibit evidence refers to any document, image, object, or animation formally submitted as an exhibit in court. It is a subcategory of physical or demonstrative evidence. Exhibits are typically labeled (e.g., “Exhibit A”) and are presented during trial to help illustrate a party’s claims or defenses.
There are two main types of exhibit evidence:
- Real evidence – actual objects from the case (e.g., a weapon, contract, or recording).
- Demonstrative evidence – materials that help explain testimony but were not directly involved in the incident (e.g., animations, charts, diagrams).
Demonstrative Exhibits and Trial Graphics
Legal teams often rely on demonstrative exhibits, such as trial graphics and forensic animations, to bring clarity to technical or emotional aspects of a case. These exhibits can include:
- Timelines
- Accident reconstructions
- Anatomical diagrams
- 3D models of crime scenes
Case Example: Using Animation to Prove a Slip and Fall Injury
In New York, a woman fractured her ulna after tripping over a small, protruding piece of metal from a construction scaffold. The fall wasn’t captured on video, and no eyewitnesses were present. The plaintiff’s attorney, Matt Haicken, had only X-rays and her personal testimony to support the claim—no expert report or deposition.
To strengthen the case, Courtroom Animation created a litigation animation that visually reconstructed the fall based on medical records and the plaintiff’s description. The animation clearly demonstrated how the metal was too small to notice and how the fall led to the injury.
“The litigation animation sold the case to the defense lawyers, claims adjusters, and the judge. They believed the fall happened exactly as it was shown.”
— Matt Haicken, Attorney at Haicken Law
Despite limited physical evidence, the defense accepted liability, and the case settled for $175,000 before trial—saving both parties the cost of litigation.
This example shows how demonstrative exhibits like trial graphics or animations can serve as compelling exhibit evidence, especially when traditional forms of physical evidence are limited or unavailable.
Different Types of Evidence in Court
To understand how exhibit evidence fits into the legal landscape, here’s a breakdown of the four primary types of evidence used at trial:
| Type of Evidence | Description | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Physical (Real) | Tangible items | Weapon, torn clothing, contract |
| Demonstrative | Visuals to explain testimony | Diagrams, animations, maps |
| Testimonial | Oral statements from witnesses | Eyewitness testimony |
| Documentary | Written or recorded documents | Emails, medical records, photos |
Each type plays a vital role in building a persuasive argument. When integrated effectively, physical and demonstrative evidence can significantly increase the likelihood of a favorable verdict or early settlement.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re preparing for mediation or trial, understanding the physical and exhibit evidence in court and how to use it strategically is crucial. Demonstrative exhibits, especially trial graphics and animations, are no longer optional—they’re essential tools in today’s courtroom.
Legal professionals who integrate these resources into their litigation strategy can help jurors grasp complex concepts, feel the weight of a story, and ultimately, rule in their favor.
Need to visualize your evidence?
Courtroom Animation provides trusted trial graphics and forensic animations to help you win your case. Explore our case studies →
Free eBook: The Complete Introduction to Forensic Animation
Whether you are considering animation for one of your cases, or you simply want to be prepared for when the other party uses an animation, our eBook is your guide to understanding forensic animation.